Proof of who owns Portsmouth remains in short supply

• Football League share transfer raises ownership questions
• Club was dogged by boardroom problems last season

Portsmouth are awaiting the transfer of their Football League share to their parent company-in-waiting, PFC Realisations. Fans hope that will mark the end of the sorry saga that led to their club’s near extinction earlier this year. But is that hope misplaced?

Throughout the ownership of Sasha Gaydamak, Pompey were dogged with rumours – repeatedly denied by both Gaydamak and the Premier League – that it was his father, Arkady, who really controlled the club. Ultimately the Premier League had only Gaydamak Jr’s word for that, since the club’s parent, Miland Development, was registered in the impenetrably secretive British Virgin Islands. Now the Football League, which became the club’s new regulator upon their relegation, has been presented with a similar situation.

For though we are told that the Hong Kong businessman Balram Chainrai is hoping to take over Pompey through PFC Realisations, it is impossible to check, because its sole shareholder is another BVI-registered shell, Sports Holdings (Asia) Ltd. Chainrai himself formerly had a close business relationship with Gaydamak senior. Indeed the £14.5m Chainrai invested in Portsmouth to gain control of the club had effectively been released from Gaydamak’s frozen accounts after Chainrai’s successful litigation for that sum through the Israeli courts.

Such are the particularities of Portsmouth’s troubled history, the intended lack of transparency is most unsatisfactory and surprising, given David Lampitt’s involvement as a director of PFC Realisations. After all, Lampitt was previously the Football Association’s head of compliance.

Clarke’s personal touch

Greg Clarke has invested much personal capital in claiming that under his chairmanship the Football League will guarantee greater transparency of its clubs’ ownership structures. He is about to stake a bit more.

For alongside David Lampitt as a director of PFC Realisations, the company hoping to take over Portsmouth, is John Redgate. Only three of the 11 companies on whose boards Redgate, an accountant, has served are still trading – the other eight are in liquidation or have already been dissolved.

But, usefully, two of those companies relate to the pension fund of Cable & Wireless, at which he served as a trustee between 1993 and 2000. That is just the time when Clarke was chief executive of Cable & Wireless Communications, so the warm relations between the two will doubtless ensure transparency will out.

Jordan able to relax

A report into Crystal Palace directors’ conduct in the lead-up to the club’s insolvency last season has been submitted to the Department of Business, Innovations and Skills, as the old DTI is now known. That is one of the matters detailed in the recently released administrators’ report that details events leading up to Steve Parrish’s close-season takeover. But Simon Jordan, who as chairman and owner through his Aspiration Holdings investment vehicle would be most accountable for whatever that report contains, has no cause to fear.

A source close to the administration process told Digger yesterday that the report’s submission to BIS was only logged in the administrators’ documents due to its being a statutory obligation, and

Portsmouth may start Championship season with slimline squad

• Club will have 17 senior outfield players if embargo remains
• HMRC challenge to administrator’s plan due by Friday morning

Portsmouth face the prospect of starting the season with only one experienced goalkeeper and 17 senior outfield players.

Under Football League rules all clubs in administration are subject to a transfer embargo and Pompey’s hopes of having their sanction lifted appear to be fading .

The deadline for HM Revenue & Customs to decide whether to challenge the Company Voluntary Arrangement proposed by the administrator of Portsmouth, Andrew Andronikou, is midnight tomorrow.

If, as all indications suggest, HMRC lodges a challenge, Portsmouth will remain in administration and the embargo will continue to apply.

“We believe the HMRC are going to appeal, that is the indication we are getting,” said Andronikou. “As long as there is an appeal process, the registration embargo will continue to be in force for the foreseeable future. However, we expect any appeal hearing to be held in October or November. Before then, if the squad is below 20 we can still bring in players, regardless of the embargo. That is allowed and is something we are looking at.”

Football League rules dictate that every club must have 20 players in their first-team squad. David James is Portsmouth’s only senior goalkeeper and there are 17 senior outfield players in the squad. However, there are believed to be enough young professionals at Fratton Park to reach 20.

This suggests that contrary to Andronikou’s expectation, the League is unlikely to relax the transfer embargo.

Andronikou’s CVA proposes that creditors should receive 20p in the pound on their dues over a five-year period, a figure that is expected to rise to 25p if the club wins promotion back to the Premier League.

The taxman’s dispute with the CVA surrounds the value of its claim. Portsmouth say HMRC is due £24m. HMRC says it is due £37m.

Calculating the precise figure is crucial to the future of the club. If HMRC is proved correct and votes against the CVA, more than 75% of creditors by value will oppose the process. That would lead to the club being placed in administration.

PortsmouthBusinessMatt Scottguardian.co.uk

Portsmouth’s debt rises to £138m

• Pompey creditors told debt is higher than previously thought
• Administrator holding meeting to discuss club’s future

Portsmouth’s administrator, Andrew Andronikou, has told the club’s creditors that the club’s debt has increased to £138m, according to reports. When the club released its creditors report last month, the debt stood at £122.8m.

Andronikou, who has been at the club since it entered administration at the end of February, revealed the figure at today’s creditors meeting at Fratton Park, according to the BBC.

Today’s meeting is to discuss proposals to take Portsmouth out of administration, with Andronikou likely to ask creditors to accept a settlement of between 20p and 25p in the pound. It will probably take several weeks until a company voluntary arrangement, which requires the approval of 75% of the unsecured creditor base by value, is agreed.

Creditors will receive a letter next week detailing the value of the proposed settlement with another meeting to follow 28 days after that date to vote on it.

Rob Lloyd, who is conducting due diligence on Portsmouth for a mystery buyer, told the Observer this weekend that he planned to make a bid before today’s meeting, though there has been no news of an offer for the club.

PortsmouthPremier LeagueJohn Ashdownguardian.co.uk